NODE 580f8106Re: FWEE!: kiosks
karn@qualcomm.com (Phil Karn)Mon, 12 Apr 93 23:36:15 PDT
Eric's comment about the complementary natures of a public kiosk and
a person's home suggests a hybrid whistleblowing scheme that combines
the best of both. The whistleblower creates his file in the privacy
of his own home on a floppy disk, encrypts it in the public key of
the whistleblowing system, and carries it to a public kiosk where he
sends it.
This gives the whistleblower plenty of time and quite a bit of privacy
as he composes his message (unless the PTB have bugged his home
computer, a possibility for a suspected repeat "offender"). The
step of physically carrying his file to the kiosk eliminates anything
that could be done to the whistleblower's phone (including traffic
analysis), although it would not stop physical surveillance of the
whistleblower.
And if the whistleblower is accosted on his way to the kiosk, all they
could seize would be the ciphertext of his message, encrypted in the
public key of the whistleblowing service -- which the whistleblower
himself would not be able to decrypt even if he wanted to.
Think of the kiosk more as a public mailbox than a public phone.
Phil
NODE b448291fFWEE!: kiosks
Eric Hughes <hughes@soda.berkeley.edu>Tue, 13 Apr 93 08:15:58 PDT
>The whistleblower creates his file in the privacy
>of his own home on a floppy disk, encrypts it in the public key of
>the whistleblowing system, and carries it to a public kiosk where he
>sends it.
This is the ideal scenario. I suspect that kiosks for other purposes
will eventually contain some form of user-available I/O. I'm guessing
it will be infrared, maybe rs232 serial. Diskette drives are too
vulnerable and expensive to be feasible in a pay phone environment;
they're called armor phones, and for good reason. In particular,
sfnet doesn't have diskette access.
No bother, we're not going to create the best system on the first
revision. A good enough system will drive later systems.
Eric